Food Justice and Reproductive Health

Nutrition and Reproductive Health

What is Nutritional Health?

Nutritional health is defined as the healthy balance of all necessary nutrients, including vitamins and minerals, to maintain optimal health. Balanced nutrition and access to healthy foods throughout life can help promote overall health and wellbeing. Disruptions in nutritional health can impact all aspects of the body, including reproductive health. Structural determinants of nutritional health, including economic and social policies, may prevent regular access to healthy foods. This can lead to deficient vitamin and mineral intake, as well as an increase in dietary salts and fats which can contribute to poor health outcomes. According to Sílvia Oliveira Lopes, MS, and Jin E. Kim-Mozeleski, PhD, a lack of healthy foods can have severe and negative impacts on reproductive and overall physiological health including, but not limited to, an increased risk for:

  • Preeclampsia (hypertension during pregnancy) 
  • Type 2 diabetes
  • Autoimmune diseases
  • Other chronic illnesses
1

Food Insecurity and Food Injustice

Food insecurity is defined by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) as the “limited or uncertain availability of nutritionally adequate and safe foods, or limited or uncertain ability to acquire acceptable foods in socially acceptable ways.” Furthermore, the lack of equal access or ability to acquire safe food is the epitome of food injustice. Food injustice is the disproportionate burden of food insecurity faced by minority, low-income households and socioeconomically disadvantaged neighborhoods. 

Structural barriers to nutritional health such as public policies, income inequality, and environmental racism can increase communities’ food insecurity and level of food injustice. The history of structural racism in economic and housing policies in the United States has had a lasting impact on many Americans’ ability to access healthy foods even now. Elizabeth Dennard, MPH, states that due to the history of racism in economic policies, Black communities in the US endure higher rates of poverty, food insecurity, and consequently food injustice than their counterparts. Healthier foods are often more expensive in general, and a lack of financial support to purchase fresh and healthy foods can lead to food insecurity and food injustice. 

Along with socioeconomic status, a neighborhood’s location and structure—the placement of grocery stores, fast food restaurants, and other institutions— can impact the risk for food insecurity for residents. Food injustice is often connected to where people live because location can have a direct impact on nutritional health. Gentrification, usually characterized by high-income communities displacing lower income residents, has led many low-income Black neighborhoods to be disrupted. Political theorist Matteo Bonotti, PhD, says that this forced relocation frequently places minorities, often Black residents, in areas that have minimal access to affordable, healthy foods. These areas are often called food deserts—which are neighborhoods that have minimal access to grocery stores, supermarkets, and other sources of accessible, healthy food. 

However, minority communities, especially those near large metropolitan areas such as New York City and Boston, are often forced into food apartheid. Karen Washington, MS, a longtime food justice activist, writes that food apartheid is a more appropriate term than food deserts to discuss the roots of systemic racism that has led to the disproportionately high rates of poverty and food insecurity impacting low-income, Black populations. Washington states that many neighborhoods with majority Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous residents live within walking distance of numerous fast food restaurants, while grocery stores and other places to access fresh produce are much farther away, often nearly inaccessible. Vivien Morris, RDN, a Boston-based nutritionist and food justice advocate, mentions in an interview with RSP that she also prefers the use of the term food apartheid because it more aptly describes the structural oppression impacting food systems today. Living in places where food injustice is common can contribute to poor reproductive health outcomes over a lifecourse that can include negative effects on maternal and fetal health. To learn more about systemic racism, environment, and food access, click here.

Food Injustice and its Impact on Maternal and Fetal Health

Sufficient nutrient intake starting from preconception is important to healthy pregnancies as well as overall reproductive and physiological health. Tonni Oberly, MPH, from the National Birth Equity Collaborative, a Boston-based nonprofit focused on Black maternal and infant health, writes that pregnancy places specific nutritional burdens on the bodies of pregnant people. These burdens include an increased demand for iron, folate, calcium, vitamin D, and protein, all of which are found in a variety of nutrient-packed foods such as fresh fruits, meats, legumes, and vegetables. Some people, particularly those from low-income communities, have difficulty meeting these needs. Lisa Bodnar, MPH, PhD reports that the risks of poor nutritional health disproportionately impact low-income, food-insecure women’s reproductive health and their ability to carry healthy pregnancies to term. Besides affecting the mother, Jasmine Fledderjohann, PhD, and Ana Augusto, PhD, remark that food insecurity during pregnancy can also compromise fetal health outcomes leading to a possible increased risk for the following:  

  • Neonatal mortality
  • Premature births 
  • Low birth weight 
  • Early discontinuation of breastfeeding 
  • Impaired infant and child cognitive development

Food security can help prevent these adverse health effects. Medical professionals, pregnant people, and those planning to become pregnant should consider the importance of nutrition while planning for healthy pregnancies and infant outcomes.

Malnutrition and Reproductive Health

Although we may think of malnutrition as a lack of food in general, the World Health Organization (WHO) defines it as “deficiencies, excesses, or imbalances in a person’s intake of energy and/or nutrients.” Because the definition of malnutrition is so broad, it is divided into three distinct groups:

  • Undernutrition–not having or eating enough food resulting in being wasted, stunted, and underweight
  • Micronutrient-related malnutrition, including a lack of vitamins and minerals
  • Being overweight, obese, and possibly having diet-related noncommunicable diseases such as diabetes and some cancers

Undernutrition and Micronutrient-related Malnutrition and Pregnancy

Not consuming enough food, including micronutrients, during pregnancy to support the extra demands needed to maintain the parent’s bodily functioning while also attempting to grow a fetus to term can have dire consequences. According to UNICEF, a lack of sufficient food can cause these effects in pregnant people:

  • Anemia
  • Pre-eclampsia
  • Death

In children, it can cause:

  • Stillbirth
  • Low birthweight
  • Wasting
  • Developmental delays

In addition, the development of the fetal brain also depends on adequate maternal consumption of nutrients such as carbohydrates, fats, proteins, salts, vitamins, and minerals. A lack of these basic necessities for human life are associated with several brain defects. Coming from a study by Maria Camila Cortes-Albornoz, MD., these are some fetal and infant brain abnormalities that can be caused by undernutrition and micronutrient-related malnutrition in pregnancy: 

  • Brain defects (diminished cerebral volume, spina bifida, alteration of hypothalamic and hippocampal pathways)
  • An increased risk of abnormal behavior
  • Neuropsychiatric disorders (ASD, ADHD, schizophrenia, anxiety, depression)
  • Altered cognition
  • Visual impairment
  • Motor deficits

Obesity and Pregnancy

It may come as a surprise to some that obesity is a form of malnutrition, but many people who are overweight have an excess of energy, i.e. calories, or an imbalance in the amount of energy and/or nutrients they take in versus how much their bodies need. One cause of this may be the increased availability of inexpensive and chemically-laden fast foods and other highly-processed foods, which we will discuss later. These foods are also high in fats and salts and low in micronutrients like vitamins and minerals. This can lead to an individual gaining weight while lacking the micronutrients that are essential for bodily functioning.

Moreover, obesity can cause an increase of insulin in the blood. As Bulbul Ahmed, PhD. explains, this happens because fat tissues release certain types of fatty acids, hormones, glycerol, and pro-inflammatory proteins that can help create insulin resistance. When the body becomes insulin resistant, it doesn’t recognize when there is enough insulin circulating in the body and it produces more. This creates high levels of insulin in the blood, chronic low-level inflammation, and high levels of free radicals creating oxidative stress. Free radicals are unstable molecules that damage cells and cause them to die. Oxidative stress occurs when there are too many free radicals in the body and not enough antioxidants to combat them. This can lead to cell and even tissue damage.

Besides increasing the chances of developing type 2 diabetes and gestational diabetes, two diseases that raise more maternal health risks, obesity can cause a higher risk of several negative maternal health outcomes. Based on data from a study by Patrick Catalano, MD., increased maternal insulin resistance and the resulting excess levels of insulin circulating in the blood, inflammation, and oxidative stress may be to blame for the possible negative effects of obesity on maternal health outcomes. These effects can include:

  • Infertility
  • Miscarriages
  • Birth defects
  • An overly-large fetus
  • Cesarean delivery
  • Wound complications

In the postpartum period, obesity can create an increased risk of:

  • Blood clots
  • Depression
  • Difficulty breastfeeding

Food Injustice and Reproductive Rights

Food injustice not only affects reproductive health; it also infringes upon reproductive justice. In her 2019 research, Chukwudi Onwuachi-Saunders, MD, MPH, defines reproductive justice as “the complete physical, mental, spiritual, political, social, and economic wellbeing of women and girls, based on the full achievement and protection of women's human rights.” Food-insecure people facing food injustices are subjected to a lack of choices that put the wellbeing of women and their reproductive rights at risk. To illustrate this, a recent study by Dr. Fledderjohann’s team found that food insecurity poses a barrier to three major rights under the umbrella of reproductive justice: 

  • The right to have a child: Malnutrition in mothers prior to conception has been linked to subfecundity—a waiting time of more than 12 months to achieve a pregnancy that resulted in a live birth. Food-insecure people also might have difficulty in paying for fertility treatments or be forced to make the choice between food costs and paying for the necessities to have children.
  • The right to not have a child: Food-insecure women can be forced into unhealthy intimate partner relationships where they lack control over reproductive choices. Moreover, for uninsured women or those with insurance that does not cover it, birth control may be out of reach because of the cost of healthy foods. Women may also be restricted in their right to end an unplanned pregnancy because of the cost.
  • The right to parent children with dignity in safe and healthy environments: This issue starts in the womb as a lack of sufficient maternal nutrition can affect a child across their lifespan. Food insecurity in children is connected to: 
    • Suboptimal general health
    • Acute and chronic health conditions 
    • Difficulties concentrating
    • Lower performances on learning and cognitive tests 
    • Higher likelihoods of dropping out of school 
    • Higher risks of experiencing bullying
    • Higher rates of engaging in substance abuse
    • Higher rates of unprotected sex

Additionally, in an effort to afford food, food insecure families tend to live in poor quality housing, less safe neighborhoods, and may have to go without healthcare and heating or cooling even in extreme temperatures. These factors are serious barriers to parents as they try to raise their children in a way that preserves their physical and mental health as well as their dignity.

Harmful Chemicals in Food

Besides affecting reproductive choices, limited access to healthy foods can also affect the amount of chemicals people are exposed to during their lifespans. Black communities can face increased exposure to environmental contaminants from industrialized food production because of socioeconomic factors and environmental racism. Environmental racism is the disproportionate burden of industrialization and environmental toxins placed on minority communities. Such unjust exposure is detrimental to Black women’s reproductive and overall health.  

Environmental toxins include endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs). EDCs are defined by the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences as chemicals that can interfere with the proper functioning of the endocrine system. They can act by blocking hormone receptors, mimicking natural estrogen, and binding to estrogen receptors. Even small shifts in hormone levels can result in significant biological changes. Common classes of EDCs include:

  • Phthalates – make plastics softer and more flexible. 
  • Parabens – act as preservatives.
  • Bisphenols – make plastics tougher and clearer. 
  • Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) – helps increase resistance to stains, water, oil, and grease. 
  • Triclosan – is designed to kill dangerous microorganisms. 
  • Flame Retardants – increase fire resistance.
  • Dioxins – are manufacturing byproducts.

These classes of EDCs are so common that it is often difficult to avoid exposure. Take for instance, dioxins. Dioxins are a byproduct of manufacturing and industrial processes and have wide reaching impacts on the human body. Preventing exposure to dioxins is difficult because they are typically present in the air, water, and soil, and because animals are exposed to these toxins in their environments, dioxins can also be found in animal-based foods. The Centre for Food Safety writes that dioxins can accumulate in fatty tissues, so they tend to be found more frequently in fatty foods such as meats, milk, and eggs. Dioxins stay in the body for a long time because they are not easily broken down. According to Dea Ziso, MS, food-insecure families are more likely to consume foods that are high in fats because they are often less expensive and subsequently more accessible. This has the potential to increase the health risks for families facing food injustices and income inequality, families which are more likely to be Black and Hispanic.    

Many scientists and physicians have learned that the health risks presented by dioxins have widespread effects within the human body. Studies from Louise C. Greenspan, MD, have shown that dioxins impact pubertal age amongst girls, leading to precocious or early puberty. This research demonstrates that dioxin exposure can have implications for reproductive health conditions and illnesses such as, but not limited to:  

  • Endometriosis 
  • Ovarian and breast cancer
  • Infertility 

Another way EDCs get into the food chain is through pesticides. EDCs are a major component of pesticides which have been increasingly found in food sources. In studying pesticide use in present-day mass food production, Nathan Donley, PhD, connects its rise to the following forms of reproductive harm: 

  • Breast cancer
  • Miscarriages 
  • Underweight fetuses
  • Birth defects
  • Stillbirth

Ways to Reduce Exposure to EDCs in Food

It is difficult, if not impossible, to avoid exposure to EDCs given that they are so common in the places where we live, work, and play. However, there are some actions you can take to reduce your exposure to EDCs in the food you eat. Here are just a few tips:

  • Replace plastic food storage containers with more natural choices like reusable glass bottles and containers. 
  • Replace teflon-coated cookware with uncoated stainless steel.
  • Avoid fast food and its packaging.  
  • Buy organic foods when possible.

Another way you can reduce your exposure to EDCs in your kitchen is to drink water from filters. Water filters may reduce the amount of contaminants, like PFAS, that may be present in your drinking water. For an insight on what water filter might be best for you, visit the Environmental Working Group’s database for their water filter guide.

For in-depth information about EDCs and their reproductive effects, click here.

Structural Racism and Exposure to EDCs in Food and Food Packaging

Dr. Donley notes that due to environmental injustices and income inequalities, the populations at higher risk for these reproductive illnesses are Black and Hispanic communities. Organic foods that may not contain harmful chemicals are more expensive, and because Black populations are more likely to be food-insecure, they may be less likely to have access to these types of food. Instead, low-income Black populations are more likely to eat chemically-contaminated foods because some of the most accessible types of foods can contain harmful toxins. In testing foods from various fast-food restaurants, Lariah Edwards, Ph.D., found phthalates in hamburgers, chicken nuggets, fries, chicken burritos, and cheese pizzas. These chemicals may come from food additives aimed at increasing shelf life and improving taste. 

3

In addition to finding harmful chemicals in fast food, some EDCs are typically found in packaging for inexpensive and easily accessible foods like fast food. Phthalates were found in a study by Katherine S. Carlos, Ph.D to be present in fast-food packaging, especially in the cardboard boxes. These chemicals may leach into the food, possibly increasing the types and levels of EDCs that may already be present in the food. This multi-level contamination can make exposure constant for some people, especially those in low-income households. 

EDCs found in food packaging like Teflon, PFAS, and bisphenols can lead to an increased risk of reproductive diseases and conditions including, but not limited to: 

  • Gynecological cancers 
  • Early onset of puberty in girls
  • Uterine fibroids 
  • Poor maternal outcomes like preterm birth 

For more information about early puberty, click here

Nutrients and Prenatal Health

Nutritional health is important to reproductive health, especially prenatal health. Maintaining a pregnant person’s nutritional health plays a major role in their long term health as well as the health of the fetus. Speaking with healthcare providers about the levels of nutrients in the diets of pregnant people and those planning a pregnancy is critical. Prioritizing nutritional health during prenatal visits may make a big difference in maternal health and fetal outcomes.

2

Policy

One of the many historical and structural root causes of food insecurity is public policy. Because of this, different types of equitable legislation may have a part to play in helping some disadvantaged communities gain access to affordable, fresh, and healthy foods. Positive changes to public policy may help ensure better health outcomes for Black women and their children.

Other Resources